Feedback Results

Magazine Game | Historical Ziplocks | Alternative & Future History

MAGAZINE GAME FEEDBACK RESULTS

Rank/Title                Issue/  Overall       Map      Counters      Rules     Complexity
                           Date

 1. Port Arthur#            19   8.18/6.52   6.74/6.39   8.06/7.52   7.06/7.07   4.49
 2. Proud Monster           27   7.94/7.68   7.94/7.71   7.81/7.33   7.36/7.58   5.47
 3. The Great War in Europe 33   7.58/7.03   7.16/6.83   7.12/6.86   6.69/6.80   6.26
 4. When Eagles Fight*      25   7.53/7.55   7.54/7.48   7.25/7.42   7.37/7.58   5.13
 5. 1914: Glory's End       29   7.47/7.29   7.60/7.39   7.28/7.54   7.30/7.36   4.93
 6. SS Panzer               36   7.45/----   7.18/----   7.37/----   6.86/----   ----
 7. Alexandros*             10   7.38/6.92   6.75/6.84   8.15/7.58   7.07/6.84   5.20
 8. Death & Destruction     34   7.32/7.00   6.69/6.75   6.96/7.23   6.64/7.08   5.85
 9. Lion of Ethiopia#        4   7.26/7.41   8.05/7.73   7.51/7.65   7.07/7.14   5.49
10. Blitzkrieg '41#          1   7.25/6.77   7.79/7.27   7.30/7.29   6.74/6.98   6.22
11. Inchon*                  9   7.24/7.03   6.90/6.52   7.30/6.86   7.04/6.84   5.00
12. Sunrise of Victory#      2   7.24/6.63   6.50/6.32   6.76/8.20   7.06/6.97   5.95
13. Lee's Greatest Gamble#  17   7.24/6.50   6.90/6.43   7.20/6.67   6.87/6.57   5.24
14. 1918:Storm in the West# 16   7.23/7.51   7.65/7.35   6.34/7.10   7.21/7.58   4.49
15. When Tigers Fight       26   7.23/6.63   7.07/6.84   7.22/6.82   6.85/6.86   5.00
16. Budapest '45            31   7.22/6.89   7.70/6.66   6.65/6.33   7.02/6.89   5.31
17. Desert Storm#           13   7.13/7.12   7.43/7.18   7.38/7.38   7.39/7.14   5.29
18. Victory at Midway       14   7.09/6.83   5.90/4.65   7.06/6.86   7.27/7.04   4.56
19. Krim#                    6   7.00/6.51   6.37/6.07   7.17/6.94   6.98/6.71   5.00
20. Chaco                   12   6.96/5.92   7.40/6.71   6.90/6.69   7.02/6.85   5.94
21. Hougoumont              11   6.87/6.65   6.89/7.09   7.36/7.04   6.96/6.68   5.20
22. Blood & Iron            21   6.86/6.87   6.65/7.15   6.68/6.93   6.49/7.03   4.79
23. Spartacus#              15   6.82/6.60   6.24/6.39   7.88/7.51   6.96/7.07   4.41
24. Antietam                22   6.77/6.66   7.04/7.11   6.95/7.16   6.90/6.80   5.19
25. Moscow Option           37   6.74/----   6.15/----   6.40/----   7.19/----   ----
26. Jutland                  8   6.74/6.32   3.97/4.53   5.20/6.42   6.41/6.63   4.44
27. Rommel at Gazala        34   6.70/6.26   7.05/6.80   6.23/6.49   7.05/6.63   4.71
28. Mukden                  37   6.63/----   6.60/----   6.36/----   7.09/----   ----
29. Cortes#                 20   6.63/6.60   6.46/6.90   8.42/7.76   6.91/7.05   4.74
30. Like Lions They Fought  28   6.44/6.73   6.83/6.84   6.57/6.68   6.64/6.69   5.21
31. Hamburger Hill           5   6.35/6.07   6.08/5.62   6.74/5.90   6.93/6.51   5.64
32. Across the Potomac      30   6.33/6.40   5.64/6.32   5.83/6.07   6.33/6.36   5.20
33. Shogun                  23   6.31/6.05   6.88/6.11   6.90/6.73   6.83/6.50   4.85
34. Bunker Hill             32   6.27/6.24   6.07/6.29   6.82/6.72   7.00/6.83   4.86
35. Tet '68*                18   6.25/5.86   6.60/6.55   6.22/6.13   6.22/6.23   5.65
36. Kadesh*                  7   6.23/7.01   6.00/6.78   7.92/8.03   6.69/6.80   5.13

HISTORICAL ZIPLOCKS FEEDBACK RESULTS

 1. Victory in Normandy#  1/93   7.71        7.21        7.07        7.35        4.50
 2. Fateful Lightning     9/94   7.60        6.41        7.56        6.63        5.29
 3. Smithereens           5/93   7.58        7.49        7.19        7.49        5.33
 4. Poland '39            8/92   7.34        7.09        7.21        7.12        4.38
 5. Berlin '45#           8/92   7.12        7.03        7.18        7.09        4.88

ALTERNATIVE & FUTURE HISTORY FEEDBACK RESULTS

 1. Mississippi Banzai#   9/90   7.71        6.20        8.46        8.76        5.23
 2. Seven Seas to Victory 4/94   7.50        6.69        6.07        7.07        4.88
 3. NATO, Nukes & Nazis#  9/90   7.23        6.20        7.69        6.78        6.46
 4. Black Gold            2/91   7.20        7.17        7.76        7.02        5.10
 5. Wahoo!                9/91   7.18        6.93        7.06        7.40        4.54
 6. Samurai Sunset#          3   7.11/7.07   6.91/6.55   7.06/7.28   6.91/6.96   5.43
 7. Back to Iraq#         8/93   7.10        7.40        7.55        7.45        4.90
 8. Red Sky Morning       4/91   7.02        6.08        7.40        6.68        5.76
 9. Czechoslovakia '38      24   6.66/6.73   6.82/7.12   6.71/6.98   7.00/7.14   5.23
10. Operation Solace         5   6.65/6.08   7.00/6.42   6.91/6.20   6.80/6.53   5.00
11. Balkan Hell             35   6.46/----   6.00/----   6.56/----   6.80/----   ----
12. Mason/Dixon             35   6.29/----   6.26/----   6.68/----   6.45/----   ----

Notes:

1. Split ratings indicate 1st survey/2nd survey.
2. Ziplocks are surveyed once each.
3. ---- = data not yet available.
4. * = Charles S. Roberts Award Winner
5. # = Charles S. Roberts Finalist Nominee

[Index Page][What's New?]